Taking away stars not due to the quality of the products but because I think I'm allergic to the fragrance in the pumpkin guts slime. The cookies & scream one is my favorite as the scent is more mild and I love the crunchy bingsu x floam combo. The witch's potion is nice too and has cute charms but does smell a little strong. Something about the spiced scent in the pumpkin one bothers me. I'll keep this in mind for future purchases!